
Were it not for the particularly lively and entertaining performances, Gore Verbinski’s 2003 Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl would have been right on par with Cutthroat Island as a craptastic pirate adventure. Let’s face it: for whatever reason, the pirate genre’s never really taken off in Hollywood. There’s something about what the mythos of the pirate has become, something about the way a talking parrot and buried treasure and rum have become less than impactful. This mythos leads to films and books that leave a lot to be desired.
The notion of a motion picture being built around the concept of an amusement park ride is essentially a symbol for disaster, yet somehow a gang of screenwriters managed to pull something out of the pile and came up with a supernatural take on pirates. Disney had a guy named Jay Wolper work up a script based on the Pirates ride in 2001. That script was based on a story by a trio of executives and a direct-to-video transition was considered.
Suddenly, however, Jerry Bruckheimer was brought aboard and director Gore Verbinski was signed and the thing began to take off. Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl was born and the secret weapon was the one and only Johnny Depp. Released in 2003, one has to imagine what a risk it was to cast Depp in the leading role in this family friendly motion picture. Depp was mostly known, at this point and time, for risky little cult pictures like From Hell, Ed Wood and Sleepy Hollow. But Tim Burton’s go-to guy was about to undergo some major changes.
Depp stars as Captain Jack Sparrow, a pirate arriving in Port Royal to commandeer a ship. He winds up right in the middle of a bit of a pickle after saving the lovely Elizabeth Swann (Keira Knightley) from drowning due to fainting via corset pressure. Elizabeth happens to be wearing a mysterious medallion, which she received when she was a little girl from an unconscious boy found in a shipwreck. The medallion begins to draw some attention from Captain Barbossa (Geoffrey Rush), who believes the medallion is the key to releasing a deadly curse.
Will Turner (Orlando Bloom) loves Elizabeth from afar, but he is a lowly blacksmith. When Elizabeth is taken by Barbossa and his creepy crew, Will springs a plan into action to rescue her that involves Jack Sparrow and a whole lot of crackling pirate action. There is also Commodore Norrington (Jack Davenport) to contend with, as he is also in love with Elizabeth and hates pirates with a passion.
Now Depp really is the secret ingredient here, as the plot is incredibly convoluted and the effects sometimes leave an awful lot to be desired. Depp’s creation of Captain Jack Sparrow is a thing of beauty, as his pirate has become somewhat of a cult figure. The character was enough to sprout out two follow-up movies, too. Depp based part of Sparrow on Keith Richards, invoking a bit of swagger and confusing the hell out of Disney execs who couldn’t peg him in his role.
But the risk paid off and Depp’s Sparrow is now the stuff of legends. Rush is deliciously evil as Barbossa, too, but his performance is offset a bit too much by the effects which comprise the latter half of his characterization. The effects, done by the usually reliable Industrial Light & Magic, actually don’t look all that good in contrast to other effects-driven sagas. Some of the designs are kind of sloppy and the entire conception of the curse comes off looking amateurish and dull.
Regardless, there’s quite a bit of swashbuckling fun here and some of the sea battles between ships are entertaining. The Curse of the Black Pearl does run nearly an hour too long, clocking in at 143 minutes when around 90 would have done just fine. Instead of being a light little piece of fun escapist cinema, Verbinski goes the epic saga route and the story simply doesn’t have the guts to pull it off. As such, Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl is a bit like a fun dinner guest who simply stays too long.
5.9/10
Trailer:








