Yet another Stephen King novel gets the movie treatment with 1995’s Dolores Claiborne. A film revolving around themes of justice and abuse, this Taylor Hackford-directed flick has all of the punch and weight of a made-for-TV movie. As average as it gets, Dolores Claiborne would be almost entirely insignificant were it not for a pair of good performances from Kathy Bates and Christopher Plummer.
Bates is the titular character, a middle-aged domestic servant living in King’s standard coastal fishing town somewhere in Maine. The set-up is analogous to what we usually get out of his novels, as the town is small and most everyone knows one another rather well. Claiborne, we learn, is suspected of murdering her elderly employer (Judy Parfitt) and detective John Mackey (Plummer) is trying to collar her for the crime. Mackey also suspects Claiborne to be guilty of murdering her husband many years ago.
Selena St. George (Jennifer Jason Leigh) is Dolores’ daughter. She is, of course, a journalist living in New York. She heads to see her mother after learning of the case against her and begins to try to unravel the mystery of her father’s death. Selena discovers that she has been mentally blocking out portions of her childhood and that the truth of her father’s death may not be what she assumed it was. A series of flashbacks reveals a life of sexual and physical abuse and cover-ups.
This tale differs from many in the King library in that it doesn’t involve anything supernatural. It is dreadful, without question, as the patterns of abuse circulating through Selena’s family are terrifying. Selena takes up drinking and pops pills to control herself. She’s a mess and she doesn’t quite understand why until she returns to her childhood home. We are shown the architecture of her internal struggle through flashbacks, including a disturbing scene in which young Selena tries to kill herself with a fragmented Christmas ornament.
Dolores is the real core of the story, though, and Selena is our entrance point. Bates plays her well, showing her stuff with a spunky portrayal that blurs reality and imagination. She imposes a sense of mistrust without hammering the easy focal points or overdoing it.
Leigh is adequate as Selena, although she overacts at times and some lines sound stilted coming from her incredibly young-looking lips. So trapped in youth is Jennifer Jason Leigh that she more strictly resembles a teenager than a grown woman and a successful journalist whose claim to fame is a Nixon interview. Regardless, she is who she is and it simply doesn’t quite work.
There is really nothing about Dolores Claiborne as a film that resonates all that profoundly. It is a simple human drama couched in the terror of abuse. Director Hackford is inconspicuous but barely present, adding no sense of style to any shots and choosing a flat, opaque approach to the scenes. The Maine town isn’t given much character and most of the events take place in flashback form or within Claiborne’s bleak, featureless home. There is no texture to the story or to the location and, as such, we simply aren’t there with the characters living out these situations.
The use of flashbacks is also ineffectual, as the main thread of the story becomes lost. One flashback carries for quite some time, as Hackford appears to have little command over including every detail in this comparatively simplistic story. And a subplot involving Selena and her boss feels tacked on.
Overall, Dolores Claiborne isn’t a must-see but it isn’t a loss either. The performances from Bates and Plummer are good, but both have more gripping roles to offer. Bates is unquestionably more interesting in another King adaptation, Misery, and Plummer is wonderful almost anywhere he can be found. In essence, Dolores Claiborne feels like a mystery movie made for television. It lacks punch, essence, and style.
3.8/10
Trailer:




