
Woody Allen’s 1993 film Manhattan Murder Mystery is a fun sort of gumshoe detective movie with a nice twist about marital bliss and showing interest in your significant other’s, well, interests. The screenplay for Manhattan Murder Mystery started out as the screenplay to Annie Hall. Woody felt the piece was a little too lightweight, however, and wound up shelving it for a few years.
Allen’s life was in turmoil during this period, as he was engaged in the stuff of tabloids on an almost daily basis. This comedic mystery was a way for him to unwind and concentrate on something less serious. It is a light comedy, for certain, with plenty of laughs and quick-witted lines and even a touch of physical comedy. It is also very sweet, especially towards the conclusion of the film, as the characters begin to find their places in life again.
Diane Keaton stars as Carol Lipton and Allen is her husband Larry. They meet their neighbours, Paul (Jerry Adler) and Lillian (Lynn Cohen) House. Paul bores Larry with his stamp collection, while Carol is happy to meet some new people in the building. After a night out on the town, Larry and Carol come back to find that Lillian has suffered a heart attack and died.
Through a series of prompts and pushes thanks to their friend Ted (Alan Alda), Carol becomes obsessed with the idea that Paul killed his wife. She soon drags Larry into it as well and they take to solving the mystery themselves. This leads them into some interesting situations and sheds light on the reality of their relationship, especially illuminating Ted’s interest in Carol and Larry’s interest in Marcia Fox (Anjelica Huston).
Keaton and Allen are essentially reprising their roles from Annie Hall, which works to an extent. Allen is still neurotic and paranoid, while Keaton is still holding it down in the balance and brimming with energy and pluck. They work well off of one another, thanks in large part due to their natural chemistry, and the movie soon becomes a game of egging one another on to seek out the eerie results of this murder mystery.
Manhattan Murder Mystery works as a nice return to comedy for Allen after doing a string of dramatic pieces. Allen’s work shooting Manhattan is impeccable, as usual, and the city streets become characters of their own. It is interesting how he utilizes the concept of space and proximity to drive the story, as the Lipton’s propinquity to their neighbours sets up a sort of “window to the soul” that makes Carol all the more curious as to what happens.
Along with being a film about neighbours and late night suspicions, this is a movie about marriage. Allen’s Larry joins with Carol in her suspicion only after he determines he is losing her to Ted. He loves her and she loves him, but they haven’t done anything exciting in years and Carol fears that they are drifting apart and into a pair of “old shoes.” This turns out to be the driving force behind Larry’s involvement with her in solving the mystery.
Manhattan Murder Mystery is fun stuff, that’s for sure. It’s an enjoyable romp and, while it seems to escape Allen’s grasp during some sequences and bends a little too much to solve the “mystery,” it’s still a great time and far better than most modern comedies. The performances are top-notch, the chemistry between Allen and Keaton can’t be beat, and the shots of Manhattan are beautiful.
7.9/10

